I am sure I will be doing a (facepalm) when I'm told the answer, but here goes...
I've attempted to set Print Button on multiple times. I've tried:
Toggling it on and off
Toggling it on, changing the God/Goddess name and hitting Enter
Turning stuff I don't need on and off (Delete, Sounds, etc.)
Resetting the iPad (Home/Power reboot)
Cleansing the iPad with sage (just kidding, but that might be next
I have an iPad 2 running 7.0.2. I thought it might be just that the journal section doesn't print, but then, it doesn't show in any section.
I can get the Edit and Delete buttons no problem.